Association of Master Roofers member · Fully insured · Based in Stirling

Mon–Sat 8am–8pm · Urgent leak? Call any time

Roofing advice

Pros and Cons of Different Roofing Materials

What are the pros and cons of the different roofing materials?

If you are planning to install or replace a roof, it is important to choose the material carefully. Several are available, and each has its own benefits and drawbacks.

A new roof is a major investment and is essential to the structural integrity of the property. A good choice protects the building, improves how it looks and lasts for many years.

Finished grey concrete tile re-roof on a house in Central Scotland

Clay tiles

Clay tiles are popular because they are durable and resist fire, rot and insects. They can last up to 100 years and come in many colours and styles, so they suit many types of property. On the downside, they are relatively expensive to install, they are heavy, they may need maintenance to prevent algae and moss, and they can crack if walked on.

Concrete tiles

Concrete tiles look similar to clay tiles but cost less and are easier to install. They are durable and resist rot, insects and fire. They generally last about fifty years, and over time they can crack and become porous. See our tile roofing service for more on clay and concrete tiles.

Slate

Slate is a traditional roofing material made from natural stone. Installed correctly, it resists harsh weather and fire and suits traditional buildings. It is among the longest-lasting options and often lasts a century or more. It is expensive and needs skilled, labour-intensive installation, but the result is generally considered worth it. Our slate roofers install and repair natural slate.

Asphalt

Asphalt is popular because it is affordable, comes in many colours and styles, needs little maintenance and resists fire. It is less durable than the other options and typically lasts up to twenty years. It is made from petroleum-based materials, which makes it less environmentally friendly, and extreme weather can damage it.

Metal

Metal roofs are growing in popularity thanks to their range of styles, low maintenance, resistance to fire and weather, and lifespan of over fifty years. They are lightweight, and they are energy efficient because they reflect sunlight, which reduces heat gain in summer. The drawbacks are noise during storms, high cost and the need for skilled installation.

Rubber

Rubber roofs resist fire and weather and can last up to fifty years. They are lightweight, flexible and available in various colours and finishes. They can be expensive and need skilled labour to install properly.

Installation matters as much as the material

Whatever the material, roof failures often come down to poor installation. Choose the material carefully, and hire a company that will install it correctly.

H Roofing Solutions offers a free inspection of your existing roof. We advise on suitable materials, check that the roof structure can support them and install the chosen material properly.

Free roof inspection

Need a roofer you can rely on?

Honest, practical advice with no pressure and no upfront costs.

07932 817378

  • Email: info@hroofingsolutions.com
  • Address: 49 Craigend Rd, Stirling, FK7 9JA
  • Hours: Mon–Sat 8am–8pm

Request a call back

Leave your details and we’ll ring you to arrange a convenient time.

    No pressure, no upfront costs.

    We only use your details to respond to your enquiry. See our Privacy Policy.